The Methodology Of Al-Suyuti In His Book Tabaqat Al-Hafaz - A Comparative Critical Study

Abstract

The article examines Al-Suyuti's methodology in Tabaqat Al-Huffaz, highlighting its strengths and weaknesses. The book is characterized by its chronological arrangement of narrators, offering a comprehensive view of the evolution of hadith studies and contributing to the documentation of scholars’ biographies. However, it lacks critical analysis and depth, as Al-Suyuti merely transmits information from earlier sources without adding personal insights or in-depth critique. His approach to controversial narrators was brief, avoiding discussions about the disputes surrounding them. Nonetheless, the book remains a significant reference in hadith studies, catering more to those seeking concise documentation than detailed analysis.